1. Understand the Guest's Needs and Preferences First

Before even thinking about an upsell, take the time to understand your guest. The secret to successful upselling isn’t just recommending a product; it’s about making the recommendation feel personal. Ask open-ended questions, listen actively, and observe their body language. Are they celebrating something? Are they here for a quiet night or a lively experience? These cues will help you customize your suggestions in a way that feels natural, not pushy.

Psychological Insight: When guests feel understood, they’re more likely to trust your recommendations. By aligning your upsell with their preferences, you tap into the concept of social proof—the idea that we make decisions based on what feels familiar or endorsed by others, in this case, your thoughtful suggestion.

2. Position Upselling as a Value Add, Not a Sales Pitch

The way you frame the upsell can determine whether it’s seen as an invitation or an imposition. Avoid phrases like “Would you like to add…?” which can feel transactional. Instead, present the upsell in terms of enhancing their experience: “This cocktail pairs wonderfully with your steak, bringing out the savory flavors,” or “Our signature dessert is the perfect way to cap off your celebration.” By framing your recommendation as a benefit rather than a mere purchase, you make the upsell feel like a value-driven suggestion rather than a hard sell.

Psychological Insight: This approach taps into the concept of reciprocity—when someone offers us something we value, we feel compelled to return the favor. By positioning your upsell as a gift, you trigger a more positive response.

3. Train Your Team to Be Experts and Enthusiasts

Your staff is the face of your venue and the key to effective upselling. But expertise doesn’t stop at knowing the menu—it’s about confidence and enthusiasm in what they recommend. The most successful upsells come from staff who believe in what they’re suggesting. Train your team to be knowledgeable about the best pairings, high-margin items, and guest favorites.

Psychological Insight: Guests are more likely to purchase when the recommendation comes from someone who is both confident and genuinely excited about the product. Enthusiasm is contagious, and it helps overcome the psychological barrier of making a purchase decision.

4. Use Suggestive, Conversational Language

Your tone can make all the difference. Phrases like, “I highly recommend…” or “If you’re looking to try something special…” make the upsell feel like a personalized recommendation rather than a sales pitch. People resist being "sold to," but they love receiving tailored suggestions.

Psychological Insight: This taps into the principle of authority—we trust those who we perceive as knowledgeable experts. When your staff speaks with confidence, it reassures guests that they’re making a smart decision. This technique is especially effective when it aligns with their current choices.

5. Offer Limited-Time Deals or Exclusive Options

Everyone loves the idea of getting something special. Framing an upsell as “exclusive” or “limited-time” creates a sense of urgency. “This is the last night we’re offering this cocktail” or “Our seasonal dish is only available until the end of the month” can encourage guests to act now, rather than delaying their decision.

Psychological Insight: This triggers the scarcity principle—when people believe something is in limited supply, they perceive it as more valuable. You’re creating a sense of urgency that increases the likelihood of them accepting the upsell.

6. Timing Is Everything — Know When to Make the Suggestion

Timing is crucial when upselling. Offer an upsell too early and it feels pushy. Wait until the right moment—after the guest has had a chance to settle in and enjoy their experience. When guests are relaxed and comfortable, they’re more likely to be receptive to your suggestions.

Psychological Insight: This taps into the concept of contextual relevance. Guests are more likely to accept suggestions that feel aligned with their current emotional state. When you wait for the right moment, your upsell feels like a seamless part of their experience, rather than an interruption.

7. Encourage Group Upselling

For venues with larger groups, upselling can be even more effective. Rather than targeting a single individual, offer upsells that benefit the group as a whole. “Would you like to order a round of signature cocktails for the table?” This creates a sense of shared experience, making the upsell feel more communal and less targeted.

Psychological Insight: Group dynamics play a huge role in decision-making. When one person makes a purchase, others in the group are often influenced by their choice. Upselling to a group taps into social influence and can encourage others to follow suit.

8. Sell the Experience, Not Just the Product

Shift the focus from products to experiences. If your guests are celebrating a special occasion, suggest a bottle of champagne or a dessert platter to share. Instead of offering an upgrade to a dish, frame it as an opportunity to elevate the guest’s overall experience.

Psychological Insight: People don’t just buy products; they buy emotions. By connecting your upsell to an emotional experience (celebration, relaxation, indulgence), you’re engaging guests on a deeper level, making them feel that the upsell will enhance their memories.

9. Follow Up Gently—Don't Overdo It

If guests decline your upsell, don’t push. Respect their decision, but offer a gentle follow-up later. For example, after they’ve enjoyed their meal, you might say, “If you’re interested in something sweet, we have an amazing chocolate mousse tonight.” This leaves the door open for them to reconsider without feeling pressured.

Psychological Insight: This follows the principle of consistency. If a guest has already had a great experience, they are more likely to make additional purchases in the future. By not pressuring them, you keep the relationship positive and open for future opportunities.

10. Track Successes and Reward Achievements

Keep track of your upsell success. Which strategies work best? Which staff members excel at upselling? By tracking performance, you can refine your approach over time and reward staff who consistently hit upselling targets.

Psychological Insight: Rewards tap into operant conditioning—positive reinforcement encourages continued behavior. By recognizing success, you motivate staff to keep up the great work, ensuring that upselling becomes a regular part of the guest experience.

‍Final Thoughts

Upselling doesn’t have to feel like a transaction. When done strategically, it can be a way to enhance your guests' experience while boosting your venue’s revenue. By understanding your guests' needs, positioning upsells as value adds, and timing your offers perfectly, you can create an environment where upselling feels natural and rewarding for both guests and staff.

Upselling isn’t just about adding more to the bill; it’s about building a memorable experience that guests will remember long after they’ve left your venue.

‍

Join 300+ venues across Canada increasing their late-night revenue with Nightlife+

Click here to register your venue!